In2000,onedayAndreadrownedherthreeyoungestboysinthebathtub, thenplacedthemonherbedandcoveredthem.Marywasleftfloatinginthe tub.Thelastchildalive,seven-year-oldNoah,ranaway.Andreacaughtup withhimanddraggedhimandforcedhimintothetubhewasdead.Leaving Noahinthetub,shebroughtMarytothebedandlaidherinthearmsofher brothers.
DuringAndrea'sconfessionsheexplainedheractionsbysayingthatshe wasn'tagoodmotherandthatthechildrenwere"notdevelopingcorrectly" andsheneededtobepunished.
Andrea’striallastedthreeweeks.Thejuryvotedforlifeinprison.At theageof77,intheyear2041,Andreawillbeeligibleforparole.